Thursday, November 19, 2026

Eagles preying on human-sized baboons upends existing evolutionary defense theory

Researchers from the University of St Andrews have discovered that hominin (early human ancestors)-sized baboons are being preyed upon by eagles, reshaping the way scientists might think about predator-prey interactions during human evolution.  

The baboons of the Ennedi plateau of Northern Chad live an extraordinary life, an isolated population of primates in the middle of the Sahara. But researchers from St Andrews, together with colleagues at Dartmouth College, the University of Konstanz, the Max Planck Institute of Animal Behaviour, and African Parks, have discovered that their deaths may be even more unusual.  
Eagles have hunted primates for millions of years—but humans and our hominin ancestors were thought to have escaped these predators for the past 2.5 million years (or so). No primate over 13kg has been confirmed to be killed by raptors and so, like the other large primates, our body sizes were judged too heavy for even the giant eagles of the past to lift.  

However, in a new study published today (18 November) in the American Journal of Biological Anthropology, the team describe finding the skulls and bones of adult male baboons with the signature marks of eagle predation—talon punctures to the skull and characteristic scrapes and ‘rakes’ to the shoulder bones. Critically, the researchers were able to calculate the baboons’ weight—with one individual coming in at over 26kg, well within the range of hominin species. 

While human ancestors were vulnerable to many predators (big cats, crocodiles for example) primate defence strategies against these land predators are quite different to those from aerial predators. Primates respond to eagle attackers by ‘mobbing’, particularly the larger adult males—who will charge the attacker to try to drive them off. Knowing that our ancestors may have been vulnerable to eagles, changes how we think about the evolution of key behaviours—from communication to group-cooperation.  

Modern primates that live in areas with eagle predators often move in large mixed groups with other primate species. For most of our evolutionary history our early ancestors lived alongside other hominin species as well as other primates, we often think of them as being in competition, but there may have been cooperative advantages to sticking together. 

Lead author Professor Catherine Hobaiter, from the School of Psychology and Neuroscience at the University of St Andrews, said: “This was such an extraordinary expedition, any primatologists dream! Some of the baboons there are so remote they rarely, if ever, see people, and so after a couple of days they ended up following us around—we were probably the most interesting thing they’d seen for a while!”   

She added: “We saw the eagles while we were searching for the baboons, but we never imagined that they might be a threat to them. Then we found the first skull with a puncture mark, and then another, and another.”   

 

Senior author Professor Nathaniel Dominy from Dartmouth College, said: “At first, the idea of eagles hunting adult male baboons seemed to exist on the thin edge of possibility, until it didn’t. Our scepticism slowly gave way to acceptance. The evidence was convincing.” 

 

Professor Hobaiter explained: “One of the most exciting observations was seeing the baboons respond when a pair of Verreaux’s eagles swept overhead—primates are very specific about only responding to eagles that are a genuine threat. We’d seen them very relaxed around other big birds of prey, but as soon as the Verreaux came into view they alarm called and dropped down to safety.”   

 

Dr Gisela Kopp, from the University of Konstanz and the Max Planck Institute of Animal Behavior, said: “Primatology often focuses on regions with a high diversity of primates, but shifting our attention to a place where no primatological data has ever been collected before, proved to be extremely rewarding.”   

 

Dr Jean Didier Akpona, from African Parks, said: “Having worked in this region for about three years, I had the opportunity to visit these gueltas (pockets of water that form within rock formations) and often observed Verreaux’s eagles. I had never imagined that these predators would target primates of this size until the research team stumbled upon evidence. This discovery leads us to explore further the mystery that surrounds the gueltas of the Sahara Desert.” 

  

The team are eager to learn more about the lives of the Ennedi baboons. Professor Hobaiter added: ‘Baboons are some of the best studied monkeys in Africa, but our very first observations from Ennedi upended all sorts of notions about what these baboons should be doing—from their diet to their social lives, I can’t wait to see what new ‘rules’ they’ll break next!’ 

  

 

 

 

10.1002/ajpa.7037 

New discovery rewrites the story of one of our most important ancestors


Fossil teeth from two caves in China reveal that Homo erectus, a key ancestor to humans, survived on the Asian mainland far longer than previously thought. Researchers also identified a tooth from another hominin species that lived alongside Homo erectus,

Peer-Reviewed Publication

University of Copenhagen

Homo erectus teeth

image: 

he nine human teeth found in Naxian and Baxian Caves – eight of whichhave been confidently identified as Homo erectus. PA1796 is the not yet identified tooth.

view more 

Credit: Professor Kira Westaway (Macquarie University)

One of the most important ancestors to humans was around for much longer than previously believed. That is the conclusion of a new international study in which researchers, including scientists from the University of Copenhagen, analysed nine fossil teeth discovered in two caves in southern China. The teeth are between 324,000 and 184,000 years old, extending the known timeline of Homo erectus by around 200,000 years.

“On the Asian mainland, the species was thought to have largely disappeared around 400,000 years ago. So it’s very surprising to find evidence showing that they persisted much later,” says Frido Welker, Associate Professor at the Globe Institute, University of Copenhagen, and corresponding author of the study.

Homo erectus played a pivotal role in human evolution. Emerging around two million years ago, it was the first human species to spread from Africa into Asia and Europe. Other human groups, including Neanderthals, Denisovans and Homo sapiens, later evolved from Homo erectus.

Analysing 300,000-year-old proteins

To date the teeth, the researchers carried out a wide range of technical analyses. Frido Welker played a central role in examining proteins preserved within the tooth enamel.

DNA does not survive in fossils this old as it rapidly degrades in warm, humid environments and rarely lasts more than a few thousand years. Proteins, however, can survive much longer. Using advanced protein analysis, the researchers showed that the protein sequences in the teeth could only have come from Homo erectus.

“A 300,000-year-old protein is extremely degraded, making it very difficult to analyse. Just ten years ago, nobody would have believed it possible to recover such detailed protein information from fossils this old. But our methods have advanced dramatically, allowing us to investigate crucial chapters of human history that were previously beyond our reach,” says Frido Welker.

One tooth sticks out

One of the teeth stood out from the rest. Its physical characteristics do not match Homo erectus, and its protein profile does not correspond to any other known human species, such as Neanderthals or Homo sapiens. The finding suggests that at least two different human species lived in the area at the same time.

“We can say with a high degree of confidence that the tooth did not belong to Homo erectus,” says Frido Welker.

“But we cannot yet determine which human species it belonged to. That is what makes the discovery so exciting, because it shows that at least two different human groups lived side by side in the region.”

The discovery challenges the current understanding of human evolution in Asia. Rather than one human species simply replacing another, the new evidence suggests that at least two species may have coexisted.

Living in tropical rainforest

The researchers also analysed chemical traces in the teeth and the many animal fossils recovered from the caves. Their findings revealed that Homo erectus lived in tropical rainforest, a demanding environment where food can be difficult to find and movement is hindered by dense vegetation. Until now, scientists believed that only modern humans were capable of thriving in such habitats.

“We now have the first evidence that other human species also lived in this type of environment. This shows that Homo erectus was far more adaptable than previously thought. Our study demonstrates how new discoveries continue to reshape our understanding of our ancestors,” says Frido Welker.

 

About the study

  • Researchers examined nine human teeth recovered from the Baxian and Naxian caves in Guangxi Province, southern China.

  • The teeth were dated to between 324,000 and 184,000 years old.

  • Eight of the teeth belonged to Homo erectus.

  • The ninth tooth came from another, as yet unidentified, human species.

  • The discovery represents the youngest securely dated Homo erectus fossils from mainland Asia.

Book: Biblical Forgery&Academic Authentication: Persisting Patterns of Guile and Gullibility

 How do experts distinguish authentic ancient artifacts from sophisticated fakes? And what happens when scholars responsible for verifying those artifacts get it wrong?

In 2016, the Museum of the Bible in Washington, DC, displayed a collection of 13 tiny fragments believed to be part of the Dead Sea Scrolls—ancient Jewish manuscripts dating back more than 2,000 years. The fragments were later determined to be forgeries. But how did they fool the experts in the first place?

Academic forgeries have been taking place for centuries—from Cyrus Gordon’s 1970s “authentications” of ancient Hebrew inscriptions discovered in America to suspicious Deuteronomy manuscripts offered for sale by Moses Wilhelm Shapira in 1883.

In his new book, Biblical Forgery and Academic Authentication: Persisting Patterns of Guile and Gullibility (Oxford University Press, 2026), Jonathan Klawans, professor of religion and Jewish studies and chair of the Department of Religion at Boston University, examines the role scholars have played in legitimizing biblical forgeries. Drawing on cases spanning more than a century, Klawans explores why even highly trained experts can be deceived, how questionable artifacts gain academic credibility, and what these episodes reveal about the ethics and practices of biblical scholarship.

In the Q&A below, Klawans describes what makes a forgery convincing, why scholars sometimes overlook warning signs, and what the history of biblical forgery can teach us about the pursuit of truth.

Q: Your book explores cases in which respected scholars authenticated artifacts that turned out to be forgeries. How does this happen? Why are even experienced scholars susceptible to being fooled?

Scholars fall for finds that support their views, even while being skeptical of those that don’t. Purported Hebrew inscriptions ostensibly discovered here in America appealed to a scholar who wanted to believe that the Americas were visited by ancient Israelites. A gospel fragment ostensibly alluding to Jesus having a wife appealed to a scholar interested in evidence supporting the participation of women in early Christian worship and leadership.

But there’s another factor: scholars of religion in general—and biblical studies in particular—often display ignorance of the history of forgery. Scholars say things like “this couldn’t be forged” or “no one would forge this”—but these guesses are based on hopes, not established knowledge of the talents and motivations of forgers.

And so a third factor comes in too: we scholars, not without reason, tend to think we are very smart. But who said forgers can’t be just as smart, or even smarter?

When scholars, ignorant of forgery, downplay the capacities of forgers—or assume that forgers forge only because of money—they leave themselves open to the possibility of being fooled by highly motivated—and highly skilled—forgers.

Q: What makes biblical artifacts particularly attractive targets for forgery?

First, there is a great thirst for biblical knowledge, and the possibility of finding the next great thing is tempting. Second, there is a market for biblical objects: collectors, both Jewish and Christian, will purchase objects that are forwarded for sale, whether in the licensed antiquities shops of Israel and the Palestinian territories, or in black markets operating throughout the Middle East. Third, there is a tolerance among some scholars and even museums for these objects—a sense that the potential importance of what can be learned outweighs the moral concerns of illicit purchases.

And here’s the problem: if we open our eyes, minds—and pockets—to objects coming from the markets—as opposed to proper archaeological discoveries—the possibility that forgers will provide what the buyers want is, well, perhaps inevitable.

Q: Of all the cases you researched, which surprised you the most? Was there one that particularly changed your understanding of how academic authentication works?

One of the greatest American forgers I discuss in the book is Mark Hofmann—of the Mormon Murders fame. There are many books—and even a mini-series—about this man. He cleverly fooled leaders of the Latter Day Saints Church as well as scholars of LDS history; and, even worse, he murdered two people and is still serving his life sentence in prison.

Why did he do it? Was it just about money? Was he trying to embarrass or bring down the LDS Church? Or did he just really enjoy getting the best of those around him?

The Hofmann case presents us with a profoundly talented liar and forger, motivated by a mysterious mixture of pride, greed, and ideology—combined with a murderous disregard for the value of human life. Don’t underestimate forgers, and never put too much stock in what a liar tells you about why he lies.

Another forger I benefited reading about was named Adolfo Kaminsky. As a talented young document-forger, skilled at producing high-quality false passports, Adolfo Kaminsky became involved in the French resistance in Paris during World War II, saving many from certain death by means of his deceptive arts.

Kaminsky told his daughter that there is nothing that cannot be forged—anything made by one person can be made by made by another. He also worked furiously, knowing that if he made fewer passports—or lesser passports—people would die.

Kaminsky’s story helped me appreciate the talents and motivations of forgers—even though I find the work of most forgers to be despicably deceptive. But make no mistake: Kaminsky’s moral passports were still fakes—they are not rendered authentic by their life-saving achievement.

Q. What can scholars do to avoid falling for forgeries?

At the risk of self-promotion, one things scholars need to do is read up on forgery. And there’s one great place to start: Anthony Grafton’s classic, Forgers and Critics. Almost without exception, the scholars who fell for one given forgery—or even a few—hardly knew anything about forgeries writ large. Scholars knowledgeable of forgery would never say “this can’t be forged” or “no one would forge that.”

Something else scholars can do is shun finds emerging from the markets. If we all agreed to rely, above all, on evidence that emerges from proper archaeological investigations, a great deal of the forgeries I discuss in the book never would have gained traction.

One common pattern I trace in the book is how scholars who fall for forgeries commonly authenticate them by making excuses for suspicious aspects. Manuscripts with bad handwriting were supposed to be written by older scribes, or scribes with low-quality pens. Grammatical errors are explained as unknown dialects.

When scholars authenticate by making excuses, the red flags should go up. With humility and self-criticism, we scholars can learn to save ourselves from these mistakes.

Q: At a time when misinformation is so prominent, what can these cases teach us about how knowledge is established and who we should trust?

I’m not sure I can offer advice on who to trust, but I have learned that even very, very smart people can be fooled—and that should be humbling for all scholars. None of us are too smart to be taken in.

I fear that AI will help forgers do their work—and I suppose we’ll find this out the hard way when AI-informed forgeries emerge on the markets or in academic publications. That said, I still want to believe that the discovery of the truth will remain a human art.

 

 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Stature reveals trends from 7,000 years of economic history

 Female and male stature by two-century intervals and site of excavation.

Caption

Female and male stature by two-century intervals and site of excavation.

Credit

Baten et al. (2026), PNAS


The most comprehensive analysis to date of ancient and historical thighbone data from Asia and Europe - Femurs reveal changes in height over generations, reflecting diet and general health


New research from the University of Tübingen and the Max Planck Institute of Geoanthropology in Jena gives valuable clues as to economic development in various regions across thousands of years. Researchers evaluated 18,457 skeletal remains and analyzed changes in height, estimated from thighbone length. The bones come from 45 different countries across Europe and Asia. The study has been published in the scientific journal PNAS.

In southeast Asia, men were quite tall 7,000 years ago, averaging 1.78 meters, according to the study. Over the millennia their height became more like that of men in other parts of the world, the researchers say, until the 19th century, when it came to just over 1,60 meters.

Seven thousand years ago, Chinese women were, on average, 1.57 meters tall; their height decreased fairly steadily over the millennia until, by the 19th century, they measured only 1.48 meters on average.

Five thousand years ago, men in northern Europe were on the short side, averaging 1.62 meters. However, pastoralist peoples migrating in from the steppes of eastern Europe and western Siberia brought with them more advanced dairy farming, and the hereditary trait of lactose tolerance. Greater consumption of dairy products was one of the factors that led to increased height. From the early Middle Ages (500 to 1,000 CE), however, height began to decline again until the end of the 19th century - both in Europe and most of the other regions included in the study.

The trend in women’s height follows roughly the same pattern as that of the men. Only in China and Japan does it decline more sharply; in Europe, it rises less steeply from prehistoric times and through the Middle Ages than it does for men.

“In many parts of the world, any written sources that would allow us to draw conclusions about economic development appear quite late on our timeline and are patchy in their distribution. That’s why we rely on bones,” explains Manon Stephan, a researcher in Economic History at the University of Tübingen. The length of the femur was used to estimate the height of the body. Most of the bones come from the graves of ordinary people in Europe and Asia, both from densely populated areas and rural regions, from women and from men. “When children and adolescents have access to sufficient, high-quality food, they grow taller, within the constraints of genetic factors. Therefore, height enables us to draw conclusions about living standards,” Stephan says.

“Our study also confirmed that technological progress does not automatically lead to greater height,” says Jörg Baten, Professor of Economic History at the University of Tübingen. “In China, for example, new, higher-yielding rice varieties and other innovations were introduced in the 11th century CE. While the higher yields enabled the empire to remain the dominant power, they did not subsequently lead to a better standard of living for the general population. Instead, population density increased: People had more children because this was seen as a form of security in old age. This meant, however, that each individual had not more to eat, but less. And importantly, the quality declined, for example, in terms of high-quality protein.”

 

Development of living standards by region

The study used data from thighbones collected in a region that today encompasses 22 countries in Asia: Cambodia, China, India, Iraq, Iran, Japan, Jordan, Kyrgyzstan, both Koreas, Lebanon, Mongolia, Nepal, Oman, Pakistan, the Philippines, Russia’s Asian territories, Sri Lanka, Syria, Thailand, Turkey, Uzbekistan, and Vietnam. In Europe, the researchers included data from 23 countries: Austria, Bosnia and Herzegovina, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Serbia, Slovakia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Ukraine and the United Kingdom.

The authors have not been able to explain all changes in height through shifts in social conditions or developments in agriculture. “This requires further research. However, the statistical data reveals trends and provides clues as to when these changes occurred,” says archaeologist Mark Hudson of the Max Planck Institute of Geoanthropology in Jena.

Milk and wine used in Menorcan funerary rituals over 2,000 years ago


  • A study by the UAB, the BSC and the UPF reveals that the characteristic “high-bottomed vessels” of post-Talayotic Menorca contained mainly dairy products. It also provides the first evidence on the island of the presence of wine in funerary rituals, served exclusively in locally produced but foreign-inspired vessels.
     
  • The study, conducted on the high-bottomed vessels recovered from the courtyard of cave no. 45 in Calescoves, shows how the Menorcan population, at a time of contact and exchange with other Mediterranean groups, adapted new vessels and products to their funerary traditions without losing their identity.
  • An innovative analysis methodology applied to organic residues has allowed researchers to learn more about the islands’ own funerary rituals and validate the hypothesis that one of the recovered vessels served as an infant feeding bottle.

In the Late Iron Age, or Post-Talayotic period, over 2000 years ago, Menorca and the other Balearic Islands experienced increasing connectivity with the wider Mediterranean. However, they also maintained distinctive local funerary traditions, such as burying their loved ones in rock-cut tombs, or artificial caves. Some of these caves contained external courtyards located in front of the burial chambers where animal offerings might have been made. Archaeologists even suspect that perishable foods or liquids were offered in characteristic island containers, such as high-bottomed vessels. Until now, however, the contents of these ceramic containers had never been identified.

A study conducted by the Universitat Autònoma de Barcelona (UAB), the Barcelona Supercomputing Center – Centro Nacional de Supercomputación (BSC-CNS), and the Pompeu Fabra University (UPF) now reveals what these substances were and the vessels in which they were stored in an article published in the Journal of Archaeological Science. The study also managed to identify an indigenous ritual conducted in Menorca during that period.

The analysis of organic residues from 34 ceramic vessels recovered from Cave 45 of the sepulchral complex of Calescoves (Alaior) shows that the small, high-bottomed vessels mainly contained dairy products. Traces of wine were also identified, which only appeared on a few local pieces, classified as foreign “inspired” given that the styles came from other Mediterranean cultures, particularly the Punic world. The study, for the first time on the island, provides evidence that wine, a product of foreign origin, was present in a Menorcan funerary ritual.

The results provide deeper insight into the offerings and funerary practices of the post-Talayotic period. "These findings reveal the complex, interwoven relationships between local communities and people from other regions. While the island's inhabitants adopted foreign ceramic forms, they continued to use them for wine—the very substance for which these vessels were originally designed," notes Sònia Carbonell, a researcher at the BSC-CNS and co-author of the study. Wine likely reached the island through trade networks, driven by the demand from specific individuals or prominent groups within post-Talayotic communities.

“The introduction of wine does not appear to imply a replacement of local traditions, but rather an adaptation of those elements to their own cultural codes, which highlights the persistence and reaffirmation of a distinct cultural identity in a context of contacts and exchanges,” emphasises Sònia Carbonell.

“The study offers an answer regarding the purpose and use of the high-bottomed vessels so characteristic of the Menorcan funerary world. But it also demonstrates how questions concerning ceramic typology can be resolved through the study of function and contents," notes Adrià Breu, researcher in the UAB Department of Prehistory and co-author of the study.

The study also validated the hypothesis that another small, globular-bodied vessel with a pouring spout—previously linked to infant burials in Ibiza—served as a baby bottle. "This baby bottle speaks to us of child-rearing and care: of people feeding infants, and of practices that were also incorporated into funerary rituals," explains Margalida Coll, a researcher at UPF and co-author of the study.

Interior and courtyard had different functions

The high-bottomed vessels have very limited capacity, which points to offerings or the symbolic consumption of small quantities of milk. Furthermore, the study suggests that the interior of the cave and the courtyard served different functions. Items such as the infant feeding bottle accompanied the deceased inside the burial chamber. The vessels found in the courtyard, by contrast, reflect the actions of the living at the entrance to the tomb: offerings, shared consumption, and commemorative practices.

The “ritual ware” examined in the study was recovered in 2023 and 2024. A large proportion of the pieces, which in many cases were intact and in an excellent state of preservation, were still in their original position, a very unusual circumstance. In addition to the small high-bottomed vessels and those of foreign inspiration – juglets with side handles, jugs and bowls – the set includes conical vessels typical of the Balearic Islands, and various incense-burner-type vessels, so far documented only in Menorca. Among the identified products, in addition to dairy products and wine, there were also animal fats and various vegetable oils.

Bringing to light what was invisible in the archaeological record

The study employed an innovative methodology for analysing organic residues, which combined scanning the artifacts with micro-excavation in the laboratory and chemical analysis.

“The uniqueness of the high-bottomed vessels has forced us to improve our analytical methodologies,” explains Adrià Breu. "Normally, the chemical tests for dairy products and for wine are separate procedures that require a double sample. At our UAB laboratories we have succeeded in unifying them into a single procedure and thus halving the amount of sample required. This improvement has been essential to carry the research forward, because the dimensions of the vessels are so small that they would have prevented us from working with the amount of sample normally required," adds the UAB researcher.

This is the first time that an analysis of organic residues has been carried out on such a large and coherent set of samples from Menorca. "This is particularly significant, as it allows the vessels to be studied collectively and the results to be interpreted in the context of consistent ritual and funerary practices," notes Sònia Carbonell.

Local products for high-bottomed vessels

The analyses have shed light on a recurring question in the study of Menorcan funerary contexts: what the contents of the high-bottomed vessels may have been. The analyses have documented dairy residues in most of the pieces, while in a minority, other substances related to animal fats were identified.

The high-bottomed vessels are handmade ceramic pieces. Each one has its own particularities in terms of dimensions and decoration, but they all share a series of common features, such as a raised base and a decorated cartouche with plant or geometric motifs. They have been documented in various archaeological contexts, both ritual (table sanctuaries) and domestic (in houses, known as “circles”), but it is in funerary contexts that they tend to appear in the greatest numbers. It has been suggested that they could constitute a local adaptation of the incense burners documented in the Punic-Hellenistic world. It has also been suggested that they may be pieces crafted by specific individuals, so their deposition in funerary contexts could reflect a certain expression of individuality.

The evidence now found contributes to clarifying the possible functionality of these vessels and opens up new perspectives for interpreting their role within the ritual and funerary practices of the post-Talayotic communities. “It is particularly significant that residue analyses have identified traces of dairy products in the majority of these vessels. This finding takes on special importance when we consider the role of milk and its derivatives in the diet of post-Talayotic communities,” the researchers highlight.

The methodology applied to the study of the pieces provides a roadmap for future research into funerary spaces and objects in archaeological contexts.

The research was carried out within the framework of the project "Ritual and Funerary Practices at Calescoves: Excavations in the Courtyard of Cave 45," led by two of the researchers in this study, Sònia Carbonell and Margalida A. Coll, and funded by the Island Council of Menorca.

Original article: Carbonell Pastor, S.; Coll Sabater, M. A.; Breu Barcons, A. (2026). Milk and wine for the departed: Menorcan funerary idioms during the Late Iron Age. The case of courtyard 45 in Calescoves. Journal of Archaeological Science.


Friday, November 13, 2026

New light on wealth and status among Europe's early herders

 


A new study by researchers from the University of Copenhagen and the Max Planck Institute indicates that early herding communities in Central Europe only gradually developed social inequality – it was not imported by the steppe migrants

Peer-Reviewed Publication

University of Copenhagen

Artistic reconstruction of young girl with copper neck ring

image: 

Artistic reconstruction of the young girl with the copper neck ring (and hair spirals) in grave 41 at ÄŒachovice. Red ochre face paint inspired by decorations on the pottery in her grave.

view more 

Credit: Oil pastel by Solveig Chaudesaigues-Clausen

How unequal were prehistoric societies? And how can archaeologists measure wealth in cultures that left behind no written records, no tax registers and no census data?

A researcher from the University of Copenhagen has developed a multi-proxy method called QuantWealth that uses archaeological evidence from graves to reconstruct social status, wealth display, and inequality thousands of years ago.

In a new study published in Journal of Neolithic Archaeology, the method was applied to almost 300 4-5,000-year-old graves in present-day Bohemia. The researchers compared the analyses of the graves with genetic ancestry and Y-chromosome patterns of the skeletal remains to track paternal lineages, including pathologies, age, and gender to give unprecedented detail to the story of the so-called Corded Ware culture.

The researchers found that social inequality emerged gradually in Bohemia over several centuries following migrations from the steppe. These migrations spread early Indo-European dialects across Europe, but, at least in Bohemia, inequality was not deeply entrenched:

"Archaeologists have long debated whether steppe populations migrating across Europe from Ukraine brought with them a highly unequal social system and patriarchy. Our results suggest a much more dynamic picture, where social differences developed gradually. Achieving status through life-actions appears to have been more important than through inheritance, at least during the first 400 years", says University of Copenhagen archaeologist Mikkel Nørtoft, main author of the study, who developed the QuantWealth method in his PhD thesis.

A society in transition
Mikkel Nørtoft and his colleague Adam B. Rohrlach analysed 296 burials from the Corded Ware culture in Bohemia dating between approximately 2,900 and 2,300 BCE.

“Following a few harsh years of “dark sun” clouded by a devastating volcanic eruption 2,900 BCE, the earliest herder communities, settling in Bohemia around 2,900-2,700 BCE, seem to have focused mostly on building social cohesion across this new network of migrants in Central Europe. In Bohemia, they did this through shared burial rituals, and building earthen mounds, but with few grave goods”, Mikkel Nørtoft explains.

Wealth differences were small, mostly age-related, and power seems to have been distributed across multiple steppe-derived lineages, with little gender inequality.

Increased competition and inequality
Over time, circa 2,700-2,500 BCE, however, funerary competition in Bohemia intensified after a new lineage appeared. The researchers found increasing concentrations of prestige items, meat offerings, expanding exchange networks, and growing gender inequality. Adult men in particular became associated with more richly furnished graves, and younger adults became most frequent in the graves, but without clearly increasing signs of violence in skeletal trauma.

“In the final phase, roughly 2,500-2,300 BCE, we see a few rich displays of family wealth through children, and the previously new lineage now dominated the burial record. So maybe the new lineage had gained the most followers and power through the competitive burial parties, and their descendants were now competing among themselves”, Mikkel Nørtoft points out and adds:

“The few rich child graves and this prevailing lineage could indicate more inherited wealth and emerging traits of persistent inequality. Ethnographic parallels could also support the idea that parents adorned their children with ornaments to increase their social value in future marriage exchange. Brides often moved into the husband’s household in Corded Ware societies, and bridewealth or dowry is preserved in early Indo-European vocabulary, and historically common in Indo-European societies.”

This could be exemplified in one particularly rich female child grave in this late phase from the site ÄŒachovice, the richest among all Bohemian graves in the study. This grave also included an extremely rare copper neck ring, a widespread upper-class symbol (known as “torcs”) in the later European Bronze and Iron Ages.

According to the researchers, these developments suggest growing social competition and the possible emergence of more durable forms of inequality among late Corded Ware communities.

Whether this development shows the first small steps to long-standing family dynasties documented later in the Bronze Age will require more data on both the Corded Ware Culture and the related Bell Beaker Culture who replaced them in Central Europe.

“We now have a correlation between changing Y-haplogroup lineages and unequal burial wealth display in one region, but we need more DNA data to confirm this at the family level, and elsewhere”, explains Nørtoft. The study also shows how combining DNA, archaeology, and language can enrich narratives about social changes in the past.


The study “Cooperation and Competition: Changes in Wealth, Power, and Patrilines in the Czech Corded Ware Culture” has been published in Journal of Neolithic Archaeology.
 

Medieval public health system in Trondheim exposed the population to roundworm

 

Trondheim in the Middle Ages

image: 

Nidaros (now Trondheim) was a bustling city in the Middle Ages, characterized by trade, migration, and powerful institutions such as Nidaros Cathedral and the Archbishop’s Palace. This drawing depicts the urban landscape around the city’s main thoroughfare, Kaupmannastretet (known today as Krambugata). It is a reconstruction of how the area appeared around 1250. 

view more 

Credit: Illustration: Kari Støren Binns, NTNU University Museum.

Ancient skeletons can tell us a great deal about how people lived, what they ate, what diseases they suffered from, and what caused their deaths. They also provide insight into social conditions and how society was organized.

Inside the Trondheim Public Library, you can see parts of a medieval cemetery unearthed by archaeologists. This was the burial ground for people who belonged to a stone church that once stood beneath the library building.

Another medieval cemetery lies just across the street, situated beneath the premises of the current bank building, SpareBank 1.

One cemetery was centrally located in the oldest part of the city, while the other was situated on the outskirts of the urban core. Archaeological excavations and findings at these two sites have revealed significant differences between the individuals buried there.

Differing diets

Bone analysis indicates that child mortality was significantly higher, and general health poorer, among those buried in the cemetery on the city’s periphery at the time – an area inhabited primarily by craft workers.

Their diet was less varied than that of Kaupmannastretet (known today as Krambugata) residents, who belonged to the church beneath the public library. The latter group represented the city’s social elite; they were engaged in trade and resided in large townhouses. Their diet was more diverse, including seafood, for example. Social inequality affected health and mortality –then and today.

MedHeal600 (Medieval Urban Health: From private to public responsibility) is a research project led by the University Museum at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU).

The researchers have investigated public health and living conditions in Trondheim from the year 1000 to 1600, including how public authorities facilitated access to healthcare.

The origins of a public health system

Analyses of the skeletons reveal that well over half of the city’s inhabitants experienced physiological stress during childhood and adolescence, caused by an insufficient or overly monotonous diet. Many people also died from infectious diseases such as leprosy, typhoid fever, and tuberculosis.

“Society was familiar with these diseases, and public authorities implemented measures to limit their spread. In the Middle Ages, responsibility for health, hygiene, and waste management shifted from being a private concern to increasingly becoming a public urban responsibility," says Axel Christophersen.

Christophersen is a professor emeritus of historical archaeology at the NTNU University Museum and has headed the Medieval Urban Health research project.

"The city initiated measures to improve hygiene, ensure cleaner streets, and manage waste," says Christophersen.

Here we see the beginnings of a public health system.

Responsibility for the community and the King’s inspectors

Erik Opsahl is a professor of medieval history and head of the Centre for Medieval Studies at NTNU. He points out the importance of the fundamental principle in Magnus the Lawmender’s Landslov (Norwegian Code of the Realm) of 1274 – and the Bylov (Town Law) two years later. The local community bore, to a large extent, what we might call the operational responsibility for the common good.

In many respects, the King’s officials acted as overseers to ensure that tasks were carried out.

Erik Opsahl, Axel Christophersen, and James Barrett edited the recently published book Health in Medieval Urban Trondheim: From Individual to Communal Responsibility AD 1000–1600.

The changes in the new waste management system did not follow a linear progression from simple to advanced, or from private to public. Rather, these were dynamic processes driven by shifts in various practices.

“Moreover, the modern distinction between the private and public sphere is difficult to apply to medieval society,” says Opsahl.

Good intentions, mixed outcomes

In her PhD dissertation as part of this research project, Elisabeth Forrestad Swensen explored the development of a functional new water and waste management system during the Middle Ages and the early modern period.

Swensen examined how Trondheim managed waste, sewage, and drinking water, and how these factors influenced public health and the spread of disease. Archaeological findings indicate that the inhabitants of Nidaros (as Trondheim was then known) actively addressed the challenges related to water and waste.

“Measures were taken with clear, positive intentions; however, not all of them proved equally effective in practice. Although waste was often handled with care, certain changes may nonetheless have led to an increase in infectious diseases and parasites,” Swensen says.

Latrine waste was not mixed with other types of waste. The two waste types were disposed of in separate locations. The distinction between general waste pits and latrine pits indicates that human waste was managed according to its own specific protocols.

A vicious cycle of roundworms

During the High Middle Ages (1130–1350), Europe – including Norway – experienced significant population growth.

Everything increased: more people, more houses, more waste... and more foul odours. During this period, the theory of miasmas gained traction. This concept was linked to unpleasant smells, which were believed to be the actual cause of disease.

This belief is likely why the authorities in Trondheim decreed that fetid latrine waste should be transported to pits outside the city centre – a measure that sounds both sensible and smart.

However, "an analysis of the contents of these latrines reveals that nearly the entire population was infected with roundworms. This occurred because the latrine waste was incorporated into manure once it began being transported out of the city centre. Roundworms thrive especially well in manure," says Swensen.

"This manure was spread across the city’s agricultural land where food was grown. allowing the roundworm parasite to enter the food supply, and consequently, the people living in the city," she explains.

The result was a kind of perpetual cycle between humans and roundworms.

Wood chips dampened unpleasant odours

Latrine waste was transported out of the city, whereas most other waste pits remained within the city limits. However, these were situated on separate plots of land, suggesting that the inhabitants understood the health benefits of keeping organic waste at a distance.

Sawdust or wood chips were mixed in and made up a significant portion of this waste, which helped to dampen the smell of decaying refuse.

The volume of wood chips – a byproduct of house construction – dropped significantly toward the end of the 13th century. This could be linked to a massive volcanic eruption in Indonesia in 1257, which sent ash clouds across vast distances. Traces of this ash can still be found in the northern and southern polar regions.

Temperatures fell sharply for several years, tree growth slowed, and these climatic changes dampened societal activity.

Wood chip shortage led to new waste-disposal practices

“Migration into Trondheim appears to have stagnated during the second half of the 13th century as well. Archaeological investigations have shown that house construction all but ceased from around 1300. This could be related in part to a stagnation in population growth. Construction over the course of several centuries had also exhausted the timber supply surrounding Trondheim. This led to a reduction in construction waste – notably wood shavings and wood chips," says Axel Christophersen.

The shortage of wood chips contributed to a significant worsening of the stench emanating from the waste pits within the city.

Reduced risk of disease

Excavations reveal that the practice of discarding organic waste into the pits along city streets where people lived came to an end during this period. Organic waste was now transported out of the city instead. The loss of wood chips and the intensified stench from the waste pits are likely reasons for the shift in managing waste.

This change in waste management helped lower the risk of infectious diseases.

Then the Black Death swept in

The Black Death reached Europe from Asia via the Silk Road and wreaked havoc starting in the mid-14th century. The deadly plague arrived in Norway in 1349, claiming the lives of an estimated one-third of the population, though the exact death toll remains unknown.

“The late Middle Ages has a particularly poor reputation, and the Black Death has been blamed for a long period of decline in Norway. This ultimately led to Norway becoming politically subordinate to Denmark in 1537 – an event often referred to as Norway’s ‘loss of independence,’” says Opsahl.

“However, a single plague epidemic cannot account for such a sharp population decline, which persisted for several centuries. This decline was the result of repeated outbreaks of the plague. Around 1340, Norway’s population was approximately 500,000; by the early 16th century, the country had only about 200,000 inhabitants,” Opsahl says.

Population Trends

We cannot know exactly how the population evolved between these two points in time. Was the decline a steady, continuous drop in population? Or did it follow a pattern of recovery and growth following one plague outbreak, only to be reduced again by the next?

“The latter scenario is the most probable, given the broader European trend, says Opsahl. “It also aligns with evidence that we observed in construction activity. So, it’s quite possible that the population of Trondheim experienced periods of relative growth.”

The book Health in Medieval Urban Trondheim: From Individual to Communal Responsibility AD 1000–1600, Scandinavian University Press / Det Kongelige Norske Videnskabers Selskabs Skrifter (Royal Norwegian Society of Sciences and Letters' Publications), published 16 August 2026.

Elisabeth Forrestad Swensen, Chapter 6: "Water and Waste in Medieval Urban Trondheim: How Mind and Matter Affected Health."

You can learn more about the research project in this podcast: Ny funn om livet i middelalderen (link in Norwegian).

Access the complete podcast series "Trondheim i middelalderen" (link in Norwegian), featuring Professor Erik Opsahl and Director of Culture Ola By Rise.